Magical Girl Lyrical NANOHA The MOVIE 1st Movie Thoughts

After putting it off for quite some time, I have managed to quickly pen down some of my thoughts on the movie, Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha The MOVIE 1st.

Update: Pictures added.


Generally, the movie did tweak a number of plot points, removed many lame and inconsistent things and explained a ton of things. For instance, you get to see Raising Heart teaching Nanoha about using Magic where it is not well explained in the original. Stuff like this, I think, would really help benefit new comers to the series as well as give new insights to older fans.

Now, for a more detailed elaboration on what I liked and disliked. I haven’t seen the movie in awhile, so I’m just basing this on memory and the few points that I jotted down before I did the video review on the BD set.

– Pros:

First off, action scenes and overall animation. What can I say? It’s Nanoha on a movie budget. One of the strong points of the original series were the action scenes and for the movie, the dial was turned all the way up past maximum. Fluid, gorgeous animation that perfectly captured the intensity and grandness of its scale.

Just take for example Nanoha’s Starlight Breaker. We have so much added detail to the scene with the buildings getting destroyed and Fate’s shields getting blown away. Speaking of the animation, something that I loved is all the little additional touches here and there that added a level of intricacy and splendor to the movie.

This can be most clearly seen in Nanoha’s first transformation scene with all the magic circles and ribbons. It’s just beautiful.

Secondly, for a compilation movie, I think they did a splendid job in pacing it out. (Well, as best as they could anyways). While it does suffer somewhat from the ‘episodic feel’ curse that compilation movies are bound to have with the fight-plot-fight-development roller-coaster ride, it wasn’t nearly as bad I though it was going to have been. For one, it succeeded much better in this department than Evangelion 2.0 in my opinion.

Next, the movie just explained things better. Questions like ‘How did Nanoha know how to fight?’ were addressed and answered in the movie. We get to see Raising Heart mentoring her, we see her training in class (can’t tell you how awesome that was), etc… Speaking of the intelligent devices, I was blown away by the sheer fact their English, for the most part, was perfect! I mean, they actually hired someone competent to write the English dialogue this time round. (Kinda miss the “I can be shot” though ^.^;)

Included with this point is of course, Fate’s backstory. Fleetingly mentioned in the original but fully fleshed out in the movie, we get to see more of Fate and more importantly, the anguish that her mother had to go thorough and her change into the heartless(?) person that she is.

Something that I picked up on was the fact that they introduced the concept of Linker Cores in the movie, in obvious preparation for the second movie. Nice touch as this way, it won’t be as much of a ‘suddenly introduced concept’ (I’m looking at you Limiters) like it was in the original second season.

The thing that I think that the movie improved most on the original series was the fact that they removed all the lame and corny parts. As I stated in the video review, the original Nanoha series lacked focus. That’s it, focus. At the beginning, you could tell it was struggling to decide if it wanted to be a mainstream kid’s show (i.e. Precure/Sailormoon) or a one that targeted a more niche audience (i.e. Otaku). For the movie, it knew who its audience was. As an example, the cat from one of the earlier episodes in the original series was changed to a kick ass panther monster thingy.

Other than that, they took out a ton of unnecessary stuff as well. In the movie, it takes only 9 minutes for Nanoha to reach achieve her first transformation while it took an entire episode in the original. All this while still managing to feel not-rushed.

Finally, just some more little things that I liked about the movie. As traditional of the Nanoha series, we only have one henshin scene, unlike other more conventional magical girl shows and if you noticed, we got to see their de-henshin as well, which is something that they, more often than not, neglect to show.

Cons:

As great as the animation was, the one thing that irked me was the use of CG. For me, I’m one who believes that 2D is somewhat superior to CG and CG graphics should only be used if they know how to use it correctly. CG in inexperienced hands will yield disastrous results. In this case, that damn 3D water when they were fighting over the ocean. I mean come on, that was horrendous, especially when they had the regular 2D characters of Fate and Nanoha flying above it. Why in the world couldn’t it have been drawn traditionally like the other 99% of the scenes with the water in it I have no idea.

The interactions between her friends and family were sacrificed. With all the stuff from a full length series to jam-pack into 2 hours, you have got to sacrifice something. This time, it was her friends and family. While I am somewhat annoyed by this, I’m not too bothered by it honestly, I don’t really think that her friends and family really have much bearing to the main plot at all. However, I concede that it would have been awesome to see that slapping scene.

…and this might sound kind of sick, but I wished that they could have kept that scene of Precia whipping Fate. I understand that it’s a movie for a general “family” audience (even though I highly doubt that any children or families watched the movie) and that such ‘controversial’ scenes had to be left on the cutting room floor. But still, I think that that scene was a very, very powerful emotional moment that showed how evil Precia was or how little she though of Fate (treating her like a mere animal or object).

My last nitpick? Raising Heart showed way, way, way too much emotion for my liking. Sure she’s an intelligent device, sure she’s an AI. However, in the end, you are supposed to be dealing with a tool, a weapon, a computer. The fact that Raising Heart showed so much emotion really took away from the coolness factor for me. I don’t know, but I think that the more mechanical, more stoic voice would have been much better. Not sure if you watch Kamen Rider, but that’s one of the reasons as to why I’m in love with most of the voices that come out of the belts, especially those of Faiz, Decade and Kabuto.

So, that’s pretty much my thoughts, praises and nitpicks of the movie. Would really love to hear your own take on the movie and whether you agree or disagree with me. (^o^)

6 Responses to Magical Girl Lyrical NANOHA The MOVIE 1st Movie Thoughts

  1. Nyoron says:

    Lol, kinda skimmed through it because I didn’t wanna spoil it, but OMG, I gotta watch this movie!!
    And I admit, that while watching the first season of MGLN, I was a little irritated that Nanoha seemed to know everything about her powers automatically. It’s good that they fixed that here. :)

  2. Izamaru says:

    Firstly,if this is based on memory and on some few points that you jotted down,nicely done~!I totally love the starlight breaker n the bardiche skills effects,so so so much better then the original anime.Plus,the background of the movie is so well made,you can see how the effort they put into it..But the bardiche design kinda disappointed me a while there.I prefer some pointed edges on the bardiche comparing to the smooth round axe blade.The round axe blade makes the bardiche kinda weird in scythe form.Hrmmmm,i don’t wanna nitpick on the scenes,the plots,the CGs,the graphics,but for me personally(or maybe some of you guys out there)the eyes of the characters(including nanoha)in the movie is too awkward,from the front view a least,the side view of her eyes are still good though…i just don’t see nanoha(or fate,or yuuno scrya)in those eyes.They looked plain somehow,and the shapes are more round than the original anime.Another thing that annoyed me is the way nanoha learn her skills,way of battle,etc in class….Ermmm,no offense but,isn’t that daydreaming of some sort??Hrmmm,i know training is good,but training without moving doesn’t seems to help in anywhere you stay(or maybe in works for animes or is raising heart inserting skills into nanoha’s mind or something??)Better stick with the can shooting for training(at least she moved….a bit)Did i miss something in the movie??or is it just me being too picky??Next,isn’t the design of the barrier jacket n intelligent device think out by nanoha herself?At least thats what i remembered from the original anime,and thats why nanoha’s barrier jacket bears resemblance to her school uniform,why did raising heart need to “select the optimal configuration for the barrier jacket….blah blah”??That sounds like raising heart is deciding the the design for nanoha’s barrier jacket(or did i misunderstand what’s that’s suppose to mean).I’m a fan of MHSLN too,not a big one though……

  3. AlastorYagami says:

    “…and this might sound kind of sick, but I wished that they could have kept that scene of Precia whipping Fate.”

    It was there, it was just toned down. Nevertheless, still made me want to punch a Precia in the face.

    …No, I still don’t pity Precia.

  4. Nyoron says:

    @AlastorYagami: LOL

  5. bonnie says:

    if fate was a boy would nanoha be as popular as it is? or would people rage just because it is a typical striaght couple?

  6. Dreams says:

    in my personal opinion
    I believe they did a great job with the story and animation I love how nanoha starlight breaker it surpassed reinforced version from the TV show
    hopefully movie 3 has an amazing story as well

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: